FL-142 item 12 · dated evidence and uncertainty

Valuing retirement plans in a California property case

A defined-contribution balance and a defined-benefit monthly pension require different measures. Identify loans, service dates, valuation assumptions and whether a present value is negotiated.

Define the number before comparing it

A defined-contribution balance and a defined-benefit monthly pension require different measures. Identify loans, service dates, valuation assumptions and whether a present value is negotiated.

Record valuation date, measure, source, preparer and material assumptions. Keep gross value, attached debt, transaction cost and negotiated tax adjustment in separate fields so no one can hide one inside another.

The source record for retirement plans

  • Current benefit statement and plan name
  • Credited-service and employment history
  • Summary plan description and division procedures
  • Loan, survivor-benefit and beneficiary records

A reviewable valuation record

  • The asset or obligation being measured
  • Effective date and market or accounting premise
  • Source document or valuation method
  • Known range and unresolved variable
  • Whether the number is a legal-ledger figure or a negotiation assumption

Unknown is not zero

If retirement plans cannot yet be valued, keep it visible outside the negotiable total and name the record or expert work that would resolve it. A false zero makes an allocation appear equal by deleting the uncertainty.

Questions about this topic

What is the biggest value mistake for retirement plans?

Using a number without its date, measure, source and attached obligations.

Can the workspace decide this value issue automatically?

It can preserve facts, run arithmetic and expose assumptions. Disputed legal conclusions, professional valuations and third-party transfer decisions still require the appropriate human or institution.

Continue the workflow